Let’s be honest – we’ve all been to that baby shower where you win a game and get handed another random keychain or a candle that’ll sit in a drawer for years. Nobody wants that!
Your guests are taking time out of their busy schedules to celebrate with you, so why not give them prizes they’ll actually be excited about?
These themed prize baskets are the answer. Instead of those forgettable single items that end up in the back of a closet, you’re creating thoughtful collections that people will genuinely use and appreciate. Trust me, your guests will be fighting to win these games!
Pin For Later!
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links.
Why Themed Prize Baskets Are a Game-Changer
Here’s the thing about baby shower prizes – they need to feel special without being wasteful. When you create a themed basket, you’re not just throwing random stuff together. You’re curating an experience. Each basket tells a little story and shows you actually thought about what your guests might enjoy.
Plus, they look absolutely gorgeous on display before the games start, and winners get to choose which theme speaks to them. No more awkward “oh, thanks” moments when someone wins something they’ll never use.
Seasonal Baby Shower Prize Baskets
Cozy Fall Vibes Basket
If you’re throwing a fall baby shower, this basket is pure comfort in a package. There’s something about fall that makes everyone want to get cozy, right?
What to include:
- Pumpkin spice scented candle (because is it even fall without one?)
- Fuzzy fall themed socks
- Fluffy throw blanket
- Small bag of gourmet hot chocolate mix or Pumpkin Pie Chai
- Pumpkin spice granola bars or fall-flavored treats
This basket practically screams “curl up on the couch with a good book,” and honestly, who couldn’t use that reminder to take a break?
Winter Gift Basket
For those cold weather celebrations when everyone needs a little extra warmth:
What to include:
- Peppermint-scented hand cream
- Warm knit beanie or mittens
- Hot cocoa bomb with marshmallows (these are SO fun!)
- Snowflake-shaped cookie cutter
- Cozy tea sampler pack
Perfect for guests who appreciate the simple pleasure of warming up after coming in from the cold. And honestly, I’d choose this gift just for the joy of watching those cocoa bombs melt.
Spring Garden Basket
Fresh, hopeful, and perfect for the green thumbs in your crowd:
What to include:
- Seed packets for easy-grow flowers
- Gardening gloves
- Terracotta pot
- Floral-scented soap or body cream
- Butterfly or bee garden stake
This one’s especially meaningful because, just like your new baby, these seeds represent new growth and beautiful things to come. See what I did there?
Summer Gift Basket
Bright, cheerful, and perfect for warm-weather celebrations:
What to include:
- Ocean-scented candle or room spray (or both)
- Colorful sunglasses
- Cooling face mist
- Reusable water bottle
- Small beach towel or tote bag
This basket says “vacation mode” and reminds everyone that summer fun is just around the corner. Way better than another keychain they don’t need, right?
Gender-Themed Prize Baskets
Pretty in Pink Girl Basket
Celebrating that sweet baby girl with all things pink and precious:
What to include:
- Rose gold wine tumbler
- Blush pink nail polish
- Strawberry or rose lip balm
- Pink bath bomb or bubble bath
- Raspberry rose soda and pink candies
This basket is perfect for your friends who love a little glam. It coordinates beautifully with girl baby shower themes too!
Boho Girl Basket
For the earthy, natural mama vibes:
What to include:
- Macramé wrist keychain (okay, ONE keychain is allowed if it’s this cute!)
- Natural beeswax candle
- Eucalyptus-scented items
- Wooden jewelry or home decor piece
- Organic jams or marmalades
This one speaks to guests who appreciate sustainable, natural products. Think of it as the anti-plastic-junk basket.
Blue Gift Basket
Skip the hassle and choose this pre-made blue gift box that’s perfect for baby boy celebrations. It includes cozy and uplifting items like a soft blanket, tumbler, tote bag, and keepsake keychain – all beautifully packaged and ready to gift.
Adventure Gift Basket
For the outdoorsy types in your crew:
What to include:
- Trail mix or beef jerky
- Adventure Begins mug
- Pine-scented candle
- Pocket multitool
- Flashlight
This basket celebrates adventure and exploration – just like the journey your little guy is about to take through life!
Lifestyle & Hobby Themed Baskets
Coffee Lover’s Dream Basket
For the caffeine devotees (aka most of your guests, let’s be real):
What to include:
- Gourmet coffee beans or flavored grounds
- Cute coffee mug or reusable thermal cup
- Biscotti or coffee cookies
- Milk frother
- Coffee-scented candle
As someone who understands the sacred nature of coffee time, this basket is always a crowd favorite. Perfect for a baby is brewing theme!
Tea Time Basket
For your more zen, tea-loving friends:
What to include:
- Variety of premium tea bags
- Beautiful teacup or infuser mug
- Honey dipper and local honey
- Shortbread or tea cookies
- Tea bag coaster
This basket whispers “take a moment for yourself” – something every person needs to hear.
Wine Gift Basket
Okay, real talk – this is the basket I’d be strategically trying to win for myself. If you love unwinding with a good glass of wine after a long day, this one’s calling your name:
What to include:
- Bottle of wine (obviously)
- Wine glass with funny saying
- Gourmet crackers or cheese straws
- Electric bottle opener and accessories
- Wine cooler sleeve
This one always gets a laugh and some competitive energy going. “I NEED to win the wine basket!” You know how it goes.
Spa Relaxation Basket
Because everyone deserves some self-care:
Here’s a time-saving tip: grab a pre-made spa gift that come with everything – bath bombs, body butter, candles, bath salts, soap, and even a sleep mask. They’re beautifully packaged, smell amazing, and look way more expensive than they are.
Honestly, this might be my favorite. It’s basically saying “go pamper yourself” in basket form. What’s not to love?
Movie Night Basket
For everyone who knows that the best plans are the ones that involve staying in pajamas:
What to include:
- Microwave popcorn variety pack
- Movie candy assortment
- Cozy fuzzy socks
- Streaming service gift card
- Popcorn bucket
This is the “I’m not leaving my couch tonight” basket, and we all need that sometimes! It’s also absolutely perfect for a ready to pop baby shower theme.
Beauty Essentials Basket
Because who doesn’t love beauty products?
What to include:
- Face masks variety
- Makeup remover wipes
- Lip gloss or lipstick
- Chilled Under Eye Patches
- Foot mask
This is one of those baskets where you can’t go wrong. Everyone needs these basics, and they’re way more exciting than another decorative item that’ll collect dust.
Specialty Theme Baskets
Parent Survival Kit
For guests who already have kids and GET IT:
What to include:
- Eye cream or under-eye patches
- Energy drink or coffee shots
- Dry shampoo
- Hand sanitizer spray
- Chocolate or energy bars
This basket is hilarious and honest. Experienced parents will crack up and fight over this one because they KNOW.
Date Night Basket
Everyone needs a reminder to prioritize their relationship, right? This basket is perfect for couples in your guest list:
What to include:
- Gourmet snacks for two
- Wine or cocktail mixer
- Chocolate Box
- Romantic card game or conversation starters
It’s thoughtful without being too personal, and honestly, who wouldn’t want to win this?
Local Love Basket
Supporting small businesses in your community:
What to include:
- Local coffee roaster beans
- Handmade soap from local artisan
- Local honey or jam
- Gift card to local restaurant
- Local brewery or winery products
This basket has meaning behind it AND supports your community. Win-win! Plus, guests get to discover cool local businesses they might not have known about.
How to Actually Put These Prizes Together
Start With Your Container
Don’t overthink this part! Your “basket” can be:
- A traditional wicker basket from the dollar store
- A cute decorative box
- A reusable tote bag (double gift!)
- Even a mixing bowl if it fits your theme
- A wire basket with a pretty fabric liner
Make It Look Pretty (But Don’t Stress)
I’m going to let you in on a secret: cellophane wrap and a ribbon make ANYTHING look professional. Add some tissue paper for color, maybe some shredded paper filler, and boom – you’re a basket-making genius.
Here’s what works:
- Clear cellophane wrap tied with coordinating ribbon
- Tissue paper in your baby shower colors
- Shredded paper fill for height
- A small “Thank You for Celebrating with Us” tag
The Diaper Raffle Grand Prize
Now, if you’re doing a diaper raffle (and you totally should – hello, free diapers!), you’ll want to go bigger with your prize. We’re talking a high-ticket basket that makes people actually WANT to bring those diapers. This isn’t the time to be modest – this prize needs to wow!
Ultimate Spa Day at Home Basket
This is the crème de la crème of prize baskets:
What to include:
- Luxury bathrobe
- High-end skincare set (serums, masks, the works)
- Premium bath bombs and bubble bath collection
- Aromatherapy diffuser with essential oil set
- Facial steamer or jade roller
- Scented candles (multiple, high-quality ones)
This basket basically says “you brought diapers, here’s a spa day.” People will be buying multiple packs of diapers to increase their chances!
Gourmet Food & Wine Basket
For the foodie who goes all out:
What to include:
- Premium wine selection
- Artisan cheese and charcuterie assortment
- Gourmet crackers, olives, and spreads
- Fancy chocolate truffles
- Wine decanter
- Beautiful cheese board or serving platter
- Wine accessories (aerator, stopper, charms)
This one’s for guests who take their wine and cheese seriously. The value here is obvious, and it looks incredibly impressive on display.
The key with diaper raffle prizes? Make them substantial enough that people think “I’d actually be bummed if I didn’t win this.” You want guests texting their partners saying “we need to stop and grab diapers on the way!”
How Many Baby Shower Prizes Do You Really Need?
Here’s my rule of thumb: plan for 3-5 games at your shower, which means 3-5 prizes.
But here’s a smarter approach: Create a prize table where winners get to CHOOSE their basket.
This is genius because:
- Everyone gets something they’ll actually want
- No awkward forced smiles when someone wins something that’s not their style
- First place winner picks first (added incentive to really try!)
- You can make 5-6 different themed baskets and let guests select
What Makes a Prize Basket Actually Good?
After hosting and attending way too many baby showers, here’s what I’ve learned:
What works:
- Items people will use in the next month, not someday
- Consumables (they get enjoyed, not stored)
- Things that fit multiple lifestyles
- A mix of practical and fun
- Quality over quantity
The key is thinking about your actual guest list. Who’s coming? What do they like? Would YOU be excited to win this basket? If the answer is “meh,” rethink it.
Matching Baskets to Your Shower Theme
Want to take it up a notch? Coordinate your prize baskets with your overall baby shower theme.
Hosting a woodland-themed shower? Add some forest-inspired elements to your baskets. Going with a nautical theme? Incorporate blues and anchors.
This attention to detail makes everything look cohesive in photos and shows you really thought this through.
The Bottom Line on Baby Shower Prizes
Look, at the end of the day, baby shower prizes should make people smile – not wonder where they’ll hide yet another knick-knack. These themed baskets solve that problem beautifully because they’re:
- Actually useful
- Thoughtfully curated
- Pretty enough to photograph
- Suitable for different tastes and lifestyles
- Way more memorable than random single items
Your guests are taking time to celebrate this huge moment with you. They deserve prizes that show you appreciate them, not just something you grabbed at the last minute because you “needed shower prizes.”
So go ahead and create these baskets with confidence. Watch as your guests actually get competitive during games (in a fun way!) and see genuine excitement when they win. That’s what baby shower prizes should be about.
Save this post for later and share it with anyone planning a baby shower – they’ll thank you for saving them from giving out another boring prize.
Have you created any amazing baby shower prize baskets? Drop a comment below and share what was in them – I’d love to hear your ideas!
With love,
Shely
